Movie Reviews by Edwin Jahiel


THE GENERAL DIED AT DAWN (1936) *** 1/2


Directed by Lewis Milestone. Written by Clifford Odets from a novel by Charles G. Boot. Producer, William Le Baron. Editing, Eda Warren. Art directors, Hans Dreier, Ernest Fegte. Special effects, Gordon Jennings. Music, Werner Janssen & Gerard Carbonara. Music director, Boris Morros. Cast: Gary Cooper, Madeleine Carroll, Akim Tamiroff, Dudley Digges, Porter Hall, William Frawley, J.M.Kerrigan, Philip Ahn, Lee Tung Foo, Leonid Kinskey, et al. A Paramount Picture. 97 min.
The film opens in a province (one of 12) of strife-torn China, with its civil war and unrest impressively staged and shot. Adventuresome reporter Cooper and adventuress Carroll meet again (their background and relationship are on the fuzzy side) and get involved with General Yang. Cooper tells us that "a bunch of us came here in 29 to fly airplanes." (For the historically-minded, in 1927 General Chang-Kai-Shek had turned against his former communist allies and started civil war). Carroll is an unwilling bad girl because she is pressured by her shady, weak-willed father. Porter Hall depicts him well as a sick man who coughs continuously and wants to get money so as to finish his life in the USA.

General Yang (Akim Tamiroff) is a kitschy, megalomaniacal warlord who, in spite of his latest successful raid is in bad shape and needs more funds to buy arms with. He commands loyal troops ready to kill themselves for him. Typically, a soldier who loses face by accidentally spilling tea on the General is about to blow out his (the soldier's) brains -- a clever scene that prepares us for events at the end.

The film is no classic like its directorıs earlier ³All Quiet On The Western Front² but it stands way above routine. Plot and visuals are quite wild in that bizarre Southern California way that reconstructs imaginary Chinas in studios. The baroque exoticism, the male-female relationships, the solid tempo, all make this a true movie-movie.

Odets wrote with brio, tough-guy and wise-guy lines where romance with a big R and idealism alternate with disenchantment. He added in-jokes, as when Cooper, named O'Hara, meets on the train a corrupt fellow-journalist played by the real writer John O'Hara. In fact Odets himself, columnist Sidney Skolsky and the film's director Lewis Milestone also have tiny roles in the movie.

The cast is good to watch. The performers have presence, both the glamorous stars and the efficient character actors. This makes up for some phony Chinese faces and accents, although Tamiroff's Chinese may sound genuine to non-Chinese speakers.

The film has great atmosphere, makes excellent use of rain, water, trains, chiaroscuro, angles, shadows. Its top photography is by Victor Milner and the superior special effects, by Gordon Jennings. The music score is lovely. While there is much of it, it is never overwhelming. It underlines the events both with lyricism (fine use of Western strings and remotely Oriental sounds) and humor (as in the inclusion of the song "I'll be glad when you're dead, you rascal you"). The sound recording is very clear.

There are some delirious, fantastic passages, as well as wonderfully corny bits, yet the film seems conceived as a serious effort rather than as camp. The picture's last words are spoken by the sage Mr. Wu (played by Dudley Digges) when he sums up Yang: "He was a talented man but very, very corrupt."

Akim Tamiroff keeps stealing the show. He delivers the most flamboyant (and arguably the best) performance of his long career. 1936 was the year the Academy added the Supporting Actor category. Tamiroff was nominated, but lost to Walter Brennan (in "Come and Get It"). Also nominated were Cinematography and Score (both losing to the film "Anthony Adverse") (Edwin Jahiel)


Copyright © Edwin Jahiel

Movie Reviews by Edwin Jahiel